Monday, October 5, 2009

Governor Perry, An Innocent Man, and Texas

There has been a lot of media attention surrounding the recent execution of a possible innocent man, Cameron Todd Willingham, in Texas. I located an editorial from the Austin Statesman, "Governor Grants Stay of Scientific Evidence," which I think had good logic regarding the entire issue at hand. After being on death row for years, Willingham's case came up to review again long before he was executed. Despite new science, new theories, and new arson investigators that found the man innocent of the crime, he was still executed. Governor Perry has said that he sees no reason to doubt the conviction and took drastic measures to the Teas Forensic Science Commission by replacing different members that would not question him. Was this just the timing or was there a different motive for Perry to replace these members? This article shines light on an issue that needs to be brought to the attention of Texas residents, so people can realize that we may have killed an innocent man here in the state of Texas because of one man's ignorance, Governor Perry. Governor Perry completely dismissed the evidence of the new arson experts. The author thinks that this whole ordeal seems shady and I totally agree. The author states that "science proves otherwise, more than one Texas might want to blurt out the kind of profanity laced statement that Willingham opted for in his final moments." Most innocent men do not use profanity when they are about to get executed. The author thinks that Texas needs to get this one right even if it is ex post facto to make sure this kind of thing does not happen in the future. It is one thing to put an innocent man in jail for the rest of his life, but to kill an innocent man for something he never did is another. I agree with the writer of this editorial, but I think that his thoughts and points could have been structured and formatted in a different way. While reading the article, it seemed to jump around and, I as a reader, was unsure the direction and points that the writer was trying to make. It was not until the end that it really stood out to me that he felt like something needed to be done in Texas about the execution of innocent men. This issue brings attention to the fact that Cameron Willingham might not be the only person who suffered because of a man's ignorance.

No comments: